November 11, 2026
Onion sets for planting, compared with seed and transplants
Sets are the easiest way to grow onions and the most likely to bolt. Seed bolts least and asks the most patience. Transplants sit in between. A set is a small bulb grown last season and dried, so it is already old enough for cold to switch it toward flowering. If your spring brings long cool spells after the ground thaws, seed or thin transplants are the safer start.
Why onion sets bolt
Onions are biennials. In their first year they store food in a bulb. After a winter of chill, they spend that food on a flower stalk in the second year. The chill only registers once a plant passes a juvenile size. A seedling sits below that size, so cold nights do little to it.
A set has already passed it. Planted into a cool spring, it counts the weeks of chill as its winter. When the days lengthen and warm, it sends up a stalk. The neck hardens, the bulb stays small, and it rots early in storage. Bigger sets carry more stored food and bolt more readily, so the smaller bulbs in a bag are the better buy.
Onion sets
- How it starts. You press small dry bulbs into the soil in early spring.
- Speed. Sets are the fastest of the three. Food stored in the bulb pushes leaves up quickly, so sets outgrow early weeds.
- Bolting risk. Sets carry the highest risk of the three. The risk climbs with set size and with the length of the cool spell after planting.
- Variety choice. The choice is narrow. Bags are usually sold by color, often with no day-length type on the label.
- Best use. Sets suit green onions and early bulbs eaten fresh. Pull any plant that bolts and use it in the kitchen first.
Onion seed
- How it starts. You sow seed indoors in late winter or straight into the bed in early spring.
- Speed. Seed is the slowest. Onions start forming bulbs once the days reach a set length, so a late sowing gets fewer weeks of leaf growth and smaller bulbs.
- Bolting risk. Seed carries the lowest risk. Seedlings stay below the juvenile size through most spring cold.
- Variety choice. Seed offers the widest range, including long-storing types and every day-length type.
- Best use. Seed suits storage onions and gardeners who want a named variety.
In our own garden we direct-sowed onions in the ground bed on April 10. The last frost we recorded that spring came on April 30, twenty days later. The seedlings came through those nights, and we harvested 38 onions between July 28 and August 2.
Onion transplants
- How it starts. You buy bundles of young plants or raise your own from seed, then set them out in spring.
- Speed. Transplants land in the middle. They skip the slow seedling stage but have no stored bulb to draw on.
- Bolting risk. The risk is low for thin transplants. A thick transplant has passed the juvenile size and behaves like a set in a cold spell.
- Variety choice. The range is wider than sets, since bundles are usually sold by variety and day-length type.
- Best use. Transplants suit large bulbs without the indoor work of seed.
How your spring lows change the choice
Bolting risk grows with the number of cool weeks a set sits through after planting. A yard that runs colder than the forecast holds those weeks longer than the calendar says. Cold air is denser than warm air, so on still nights it drains into low ground and pools there.
Our station learned that our garden runs 7°F colder than the forecast. That offset moves our planning last frost from the published April 28 to May 20. Sets planted on the published date in our yard would sit through about three more weeks of cold nights than the calendar suggests. Our guide on why your last frost date is probably wrong covers where that gap comes from.
Frost alerts run for every garden, free and Pro. At 17:00 local time Siltwell checks the forecast lows for tomorrow and the day after against your frost threshold, which defaults to 0 °C (32°F). The garden owner can raise that threshold as high as 20 °C. Set it a few degrees above freezing for the weeks after your sets go in, and the alerts flag the cool nights they sit through.
On a free account you enter the offset yourself under Settings, Garden, Edit garden, Microclimate offset, using a negative number for a colder site. With a connected station on Pro, Siltwell learns the offset from the station's outdoor air temperature after about 14 days of overlapping station and forecast readings. The microclimate checker compares nearby home weather stations with the forecast model over recent nights and returns a range for your area, which gives you a starting number.
An alert flags cold nights. It can't tell you when a particular set has banked enough chill to bolt, because that depends on the set's size and variety, and nothing in the app measures either.
Which one for you
- Sets. Pick them if your spring warms steadily after the thaw and you want green onions or early bulbs fast.
- Seed. Pick it if your yard holds cold late, you want storage onions, or you want a named variety.
- Transplants. Pick them if you want big bulbs this year and spring cold snaps worry you. Choose the thinnest plants in the bundle.
If you plant in fall instead, the timing runs off your first frost, and planting onions in winter against your real first frost covers that schedule.
If you're planting sets this spring, sort the bag by size before you plant. Space the smallest bulbs out for full-size onions. Crowd the largest into one row as green onions and pull them early, since they are the ones most likely to bolt.
Common questions.
- Are onion sets better than seeds?
- Sets are better for speed, and seed is better for bulbs that store. The bulb in a set carries its own food, so leaves come up fast, but sets bolt more often after a cool spring. Seed takes longer, rarely bolts from spring cold, and offers far more varieties.
- When should onion sets be planted?
- Plant sets in early spring, once the soil can be worked and the long cool spells are behind you. Onions tolerate frost, so a light freeze after planting won't kill them. Weeks of cool weather after planting raise the bolting risk. A yard that holds cold late does better planting a little later or starting from seed.
- Why do onion sets bolt?
- A set bolts when cool weather after planting registers as winter. Onions only count chill once they pass a juvenile size, and a set has already passed it. A long cool spell followed by lengthening days triggers a flower stalk, and large sets do this more readily than small ones.
- How deep do you plant onion sets?
- Plant sets with the pointed tip level with the soil surface or barely covered. A deep set spends its stored food pushing up through extra soil before it makes leaves. Birds and frost heave can lift shallow sets, so firm the soil around each one and replant any that pop out.
Related guides
Planting tobacco from seed by your real last frost
How to start tobacco from dust-fine seed indoors, harden it off, and set it out after the last frost your own yard gets.
How to prepare seed potatoes for planting
Sprout, cut, cure and plant seed potatoes in order, and time planting so the shoots come up after your yard's last frost.
Does planting grass seed in winter work?
When winter-sown grass seed sits dormant, when it sprouts too early, and how snow, frost and your soil temperature decide which happens.
Free planting tools
- When to plant shows the last date to sow each crop before your fall frost.
- Microclimate checker shows how much colder or warmer gardens near you ran than the forecast low.
- GDD estimator adds up a typical season's heat and shows which crops can ripen where you are.
