November 6, 2026
Planting onions in winter by your yard's real first frost
Onions planted for winter need roots in the ground before the soil freezes, and that deadline follows your own yard's first frost. Find that date, count back from it, and set onion sets or short-day transplants into moist soil while it still holds summer heat. A regional chart gives one frost date for a wide area. Your yard can reach frost weeks earlier.
Why your first frost sets the date
An onion set is a small dormant bulb. In moist soil it pushes roots down and leaves up. The roots anchor the plant and pull water into it. Soil holds heat longer than air, so roots keep growing for a while after the first frosty night.
Trouble starts when the top layer of soil freezes and thaws over and over. Water in the soil expands as it freezes, and the ground lifts anything without roots to hold it. A rootless set ends up on the surface, where wind dries it out.
The regional chart puts our garden's first frost on October 22. In 2025 a freeze reached our beds on October 3, 19 days ahead of that chart date. Our station learned that our site runs 7°F colder than the forecast, which moves our effective first frost to September 30. A planting date counted from the chart would have put our onions in about three weeks late. This year our onions went in by direct seed on April 10, and the bed gave us 38 bulbs by early August. The fall timing below runs on the same frost data.
1. Check your area's frost offset
Run the microclimate checker. The microclimate checker compares nearby home weather stations with the forecast model over recent nights and returns a range for your area. Three or more stations give a high confidence reading. One or two give moderate. Take the median as your starting offset. It describes your area, and your own yard can sit warmer or colder.
2. Enter the offset in Siltwell
On a free account you enter the offset yourself under Settings, Garden, Edit garden, Microclimate offset, using a negative number for a colder site. The field takes degrees Celsius, so convert a Fahrenheit range first. The offset moves your first and last frost dates in the app by up to 30 days. It also shifts the forecast lows behind your frost alerts.
With a connected station on Pro, Siltwell learns the offset from the station's outdoor air temperature after about 14 days of overlapping station and forecast readings. Until then, any manual offset you entered stays in use. Station setup walks through the connection.
3. Choose small sets of a winter type
Day length tells an onion when to bulb. Short-day types start bulbing early as spring days lengthen, so they fit a fall planting in mild-winter yards. Buy small sets. A large set that sits through a cold spell can switch to flowering in spring. A flowering onion stops building its bulb.
4. Count back from your adjusted first frost
Plant early enough for roots to settle before the ground freezes. We can't give you a fixed number of weeks, because the gap depends on how fast your soil cools. Suppose the chart says October 25 and your adjusted first frost lands on October 10. Count back from October 10. Set each bulb pointed end up in moist soil, with the tip level with the surface.
5. Mulch once the onions have rooted
Mulch slows the soil's heat loss on cold nights. It also damps the freeze and thaw swings that heave young plants. Spread straw after the onions have rooted and the first hard freezes arrive. Mulch laid on warm, wet soil holds moisture against the bulbs and invites rot.
6. Watch the frost alerts
Frost alerts run for every garden, free and Pro. At 17:00 local time Siltwell checks the forecast lows for tomorrow and the day after against your frost threshold, which defaults to 0 °C (32°F). With a manual offset entered, the alert says it was adjusted for your site. The first alert of the fall tells you the window for root growth is closing. If your sets aren't in by then, plant them that week.
What can go wrong
- Sets heave out. Late sets with few roots get lifted by freeze and thaw. Press them back in and mulch the bed.
- Onions bolt in spring. Large sets exposed to cold can flower. Pull bolting onions and eat them early, since the bulb won't grow further.
- Bulbs rot. Winter rain sits around bulbs in heavy soil. Our garden took 1.73 in of rain in January 2026 and 2.88 in in February, so we'd plant in a well-drained bed.
- The offset misses a low spot. Cold air is denser and drains downhill on still nights. A hollow can run colder than every station the checker found.
The offset tracks air temperature. It can't tell you the night your soil freezes, and that night is the deadline your onion roots face. Soil usually freezes later than the air, and later still under mulch, so treat the adjusted first frost as an early warning with some margin behind it.
Garlic runs on the same calendar, and our guide to planting garlic over winter covers its timing. Once your offset is set, check the spring side too. Our guide on why your last frost date is probably wrong shows how the same offset moves your spring planting. This week, run the checker, enter the median, and write your onion planting date on the calendar against the adjusted first frost.
Common questions.
- Can you plant onions in winter?
- Yes, in yards where the ground stays workable into late fall, onion sets and short-day transplants can go in before the soil freezes. They sit through the cold as small plants and start growing again as the days lengthen. Where the ground freezes hard and early, a spring planting is the safer call.
- When should onion sets go in before the first frost?
- Plant them early enough for roots to establish before the soil freezes, and count back from your yard's own first frost. The published date can mislead you. In our own garden the first fall frost of 2025 came on October 3, 19 days ahead of the published October 22.
- Will frost kill newly planted onions?
- A light frost seldom kills an onion that has rooted. The danger falls on late sets with few roots. Repeated freezing and thawing expands the top layer of soil and lifts them out, and a lifted set dries in the wind. Press heaved sets back into the soil and mulch the bed.
- How cold can overwintering onions handle?
- We don't have a measured kill temperature for onions, and the published figures disagree. Hardiness shifts with the onion type, the plant's size, and how cold the soil around the bulb gets. Mulch slows the soil's heat loss, so a mulched bulb sits warmer than the air reading. Our coldest night of 2026 reached 3°F on January 9, and a low like that is worth planning mulch around.
Related guides
Planting garlic over winter by your yard's real first frost
When to plant garlic in fall by your yard's own first frost date, how deep to set the cloves, and when to mulch them for winter.
Planting pumpkin seeds after your yard's real last frost
When to plant pumpkin seeds by your yard's last frost, how to count back from first frost, and how to sow so the seeds don't rot.
Preparing raised beds for winter by your real first-frost date
Learn how to time mulch, compost, cover crops, and your last watering to your yard's real first-frost date instead of the regional average.
Free planting tools
- When to plant shows the last date to sow each crop before your fall frost.
- Microclimate checker shows how much colder or warmer gardens near you ran than the forecast low.
- GDD estimator adds up a typical season's heat and shows which crops can ripen where you are.
