Pick Planta
Planta fits if your plants live in pots on windowsills. Its photo identification, Dr. Planta diagnosis, light meter, and per-plant care schedules are best-in-class. Nothing in Siltwell replaces them.
Side-by-side comparison
Siltwell vs Planta for food gardeners
Planta is one of the most polished plant-care apps ever made, with 4.8 stars from over 100k ratings. But caring for a monstera and planning a vegetable garden are different jobs. We compare both below so you can pick the right tool, or use both.
SiltwellPlanta
- Built forSiltwell · Outdoor vegetable beds, from planning and planting to harvestPlanta · Plant care for indoor & outdoor collections, houseplants first
- Photo plant ID & disease diagnosisSiltwell · Siltwell doesn't do thisPlanta · Photo ID plus “Dr. Planta” diagnosis & treatment plans
- Care remindersSiltwell · Watering guidance that reads your forecast (free)Planta · Smart schedules per plant, informed by local climate data
- Visual bed layout editorSiltwell · Free, with crop-rotation + companion warningsPlanta · No garden-bed layout planner
- Planting calendar from frost datesSiltwell · Free, from your own frost dates (US coverage)Planta · Not advertised
- Succession planning & harvest trackingSiltwell · FreePlanta · Seed & propagation tracking; no harvest log advertised
- Journal with photosSiltwell · Free (100-photo quota; unlimited on Pro)Planta · Plant journal & progress tracking
- Light meterSiltwell · Planta · Built-in
- Weather-station / soil-sensor connectSiltwell · Pro: Ecowitt, Davis, Ambient, WeatherFlow TempestPlanta ·
- PlatformsSiltwell · Web + iPhone + Android, works offlinePlanta · iPhone + Android
- PriceSiltwell · Core is free. Pro $22/yr founding, list $39 (14-day trial)Planta · Free tier; Premium $7.99–9.99/mo or $35.99–47.99/yr
Planta details verified from getplanta.com and its App Store listing, August 2026. Spot something outdated? Tell us.
When each one wins.
Pick Siltwell
Siltwell fits if you're planning vegetable beds. It gives you a free layout editor with rotation and companion warnings, a planting calendar built from your frost dates, harvest tracking, and watering guidance that reads the forecast. Planta isn't built for any of those jobs.
Use both
Plenty of gardeners run both, with Planta for the houseplant collection and Siltwell for the veg patch. Siltwell's core is free, so trying it alongside Planta costs nothing.
Compare for yourself